• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Travel
  • Sustainability
  • Food
  • Expat Life
  • Reviews
  • Resources & Recommendations
  • All Blog Posts
  • About ⋁
    • Contact
    • Work With Me
    • Press & Portfolio
    • Privacy
  • Tilted Map
  • Nav Social Menu

    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • RSS
    • Twitter
Tilted Map

Tilted Map

Travel, sustainability & life between two cultures

Pollution, Communism & China: Teaching the Documentary “Under the Dome”

June 7, 2015 by Ketti 1 Comment

Communist leader Mao Zedong as a decoration on the dashboard of a Chinese taxi.

What follows is my experience discussing communism and pollution with my Chinese university students after showing “Under The Dome,” a Chinese documentary about pollution by journalist Chai Jing, in my classroom.


This was a bad week for people in China who like journalism.

This was the week when a cruise ship sank on the Yangtze River and killed 440 people with no explanation, but Chinese media were forced to change the headlines to “18 People Rescued From Cruise Ship.”

Chinese Censorship 101

Of course, this week was also the anniversary of the Tiananmen Square Massacre. (Or, as I’ve been thinking of it, while reading over lists of hundreds of words that will prompt Chinese censors to delete a social media post, Censorship Awareness Day.)

Last year, two days before the 25th anniversary of the massacre, China commemorated the event by blocking Google. This year it didn’t have to, because all Google services are still blocked here in mainland China. So are YouTube, Facebook, Twitter, WordPress, this blog about life in China, and a good deal of the outside world’s journalism. (The New York Times and BBC are blocked, but a lot of sites featuring snippets of their content, such as The Daily Beast and The Week, are still accessible. This is why all expats and many locals here use a VPN.)

This week, in the college English classes I teach, I gave a lecture about Western taboos.

In my class with the most open-minded students, I segued from offending a conversation partner to offending the government. On Thursday, June 4, I asked my students what had happened on that date in China in 1989. At first none of them seemed to have any idea. Then one student said he knew. His father had been on his way to the protests in Beijing, but had been called back to work – a call that, as he told the class, maybe saved his father’s life.

Teaching about pollution in China means sneaking past censorship, just like this altered photo of Tank Man facing down rubber ducks.
The famous Tiananmen Square Tank Man photo – disguised, in an attempt to sneak the image past censors on Chinese social media. Not to be outdone, the government added “big yellow duck” to the list of banned search terms.
Many students were still confused and one asked me outright if I knew the story of the massacre.

I answered that yes, I did. To my surprise, they wanted me to tell them (which I hadn’t planned to do). But I also didn’t feel it was right to say, “no, no, you’ll have to go read about it online.” If they don’t have access to a good VPN, they can’t go read about it online. And it’s certainly not in university library books.

So I gently outlined the events: Students demanding democratic reforms and an end to corruption. Tank Man. A death civilian toll estimated in the thousands.

They asked if all foreigners knew about this. Yes, I told them yes, and it’s in school textbooks in the U.S. This detail shocked them more than any other. The hardest part was seeing them look defeated and, most strikingly, embarrassed by not knowing their country’s history.

That was one of the days when I felt like my job was actually important. I was actually doing something for these students that no one else had, instead of just correcting the same grammar mistakes week after week.

Teaching “Under the Dome“

Another time like that, and one of my favorite weeks teaching here, was when I showed a clip from a documentary called Under The Dome and led a discussion – with the classroom doors closed – about pollution, corruption, and censorship.

Under the Dome is a film by independent Chinese journalist Chai Jing. Back when people were talking about it, it was likened to a Chinese version of An Inconvenient Truth – unprecedented, controversial, and game-changing.

The film was released for free online on February 28 – including on the website of the communist party’s newspaper. It was praised by China’s environmental minister. Then it was banned by the party one week later, after about 200 million views in China.

Very few of those viewers were my students in the huge, but rather provincial city of Jinan. In most of my classes, two or three students had heard of the film. And maybe only one had watched a portion of it. I showed the first few minutes of it. When I turned the lights back on, half of my students had tears in their eyes in each of my six classes. Here’s what they saw:

My students’ reactions really surprised me, even though they were logical.

We live in the seventh smoggiest city in all of China. And a lot of students, at least here in the relative sticks, aren’t entirely aware that their government censors the Internet.

But some of their comments in our discussions floored me. First among them was the student who reminded me why I had chosen to show the film in the first place: “Ignoring the problem is the biggest problem.”

Here are some other comments from my students while discussing Under the Dome:

“I think,” one student told the class, “the government thinks the more truth the people know, the more troubles the government will suffer.”

“I think she’s the only journalist to tell the truth,” one student said of Chai Jing, the reporter who made the film.

“Everyone in China is ‘under the dome,’” said another student. “That’s a Chinese fact.”

“We ordinary people want to change,” another commented, “but we don’t have the power.”

One of the maxims that stuck in my head from journalism school is “sunshine is the best disinfectant.”

The rise and fall of Under The Dome is just one more anecdote on how little sunshine breaks through here, in the literal or figurative sense.

Still, one of my friends told me Under The Dome had been playing on loop at his gym weeks after it was banned by the communist party’s censors. A few students reported they could still find the documentary online, even without a VPN. A couple even enthusiastically asked if I could give them a copy of the entire film.

Their interest and perceptiveness impressed me. Mostly because, in my year two semesters of teaching university English here in China, I’ve realized college students here seem much less worldly than in the West.

And that is certainly by design. China’s education minister recently said this: 

“We must, by no means, allow into our classrooms material that propagates Western values.”

And yet, here I am.

I can’t fault the Chinese for wanting self-determination; after all, the U.S. wouldn’t encourage material that propagates supposedly communist Chinese values in schools. But we would never hear a high-level official being so blunt, and frankly so honest, about it without serious backlash. The problem is, this isn’t just about individual or national self-determination; it’s about citizens not seeing any other views besides the one handed down from the elite group that is the Chinese Communist Party.

The Scary Side of Censorship

Since January, the government has been cracking down on VPNs (a kind of software for accessing blocked websites, as I explain in this post, as if the user were outside of China). They’ve also increased censorship in general since last year’s Tiananmen anniversary. (Many commercial VPNs don’t work as well as they used to, but many underground programs are still running well.)

For me, this has been one of the most frustrating things about living in China. Not just because it’s inconvenient to have to use slow, unreliable VPNs to get to the real Internet – although that is a factor that gets exhausting. But also because not having the freedoms of expression or information is philosophically terrifying.

And it’s occasionally terrifying in a less philosophical, more literal sense, such as when I read about Chinese journalists asking good questions and then disappearing. Or perhaps instead of disappearing, being “invited” for “tea” with the “police.”

Knowing such power is out there, that it’s real and it’s the current regime of the country where I live (for reasons that sometimes escape me), is scary. It’s infuriating and sometimes humbling, but I still can’t bring myself to shut up about it.

Right now, it seems nothing is too petty for the censors here to block. But I’m convinced they won’t be able to keep it up for very long.

Based on what I see every time I leave my apartment, roughly everyone in China is online 100% of the time. As more people discover how easy it is (even after the crack-down) to download a VPN and make a Facebook account or watch American TV shows on YouTube, the government’s façade of “Internet sovereignty,” (the term they use to justify censorship) will crack.

It’s unimaginable to me that such devout Internet lovers as the Chinese of my generation would continue to accept the imitation Internet they’re being fed. The only questions are how long it will be before Beijing admits it can’t control information in the Information Age, and how much drama we will all have to endure before that happens.

UPDATE:

I published this blog post just a few weeks before finishing my teaching job and leaving China. (I should have waited to publish it after leaving the country; I’m not sure why I didn’t.)

A few days later, I got a call from a university leader about some random administrative topic. I couldn’t quite figure out why she was calling me about it, until the subject changed. She told me, “I have this article, about ‘Teaching Under the Dome,’ printed out…” My blood went a little cold. I forgot some of the details of what she said, as I was waiting for the hammer to drop. But I remember this: “You cannot write this kind of thing, Ketti. You have your rights, but not in China.”


Related

Filed Under: China, Expat Life, Sustainability Tagged With: Eco, Teaching English

Reader Interactions

Trackbacks

  1. “Apocalypto” | The Wilhelm Scream says:
    November 16, 2016 at 3:08 PM

    […] we elect a leader who doesn’t want to fight climate change, we tell countries like China, “Yeah, we don’t really care about pollution […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Welcome to Tilted Map! A travel blog about sustainability & culture.

I’m Ketti, and I started blogging when I moved from Montana to China on a whim. That turned into 5 years abroad, a master’s in sustainability and a passion for travel!
On this site, you’ll find a lot about US & Italian cultural differences (which, of course, includes a lot about food) plus travel ideas and plastic-free product reviews. Hit me up with questions! Read More on My About Page…

Subscribe here!

Popular Posts:

The view of steep cliffs and turquoise waters from the front of a long tail boat in Thailand. ©KettiWilhelm2019

My Favorite Non-fiction Books for Traveling Vicariously While Stuck at Home

A plate of spaghetti con vongole (spaghetti with fresh clams) in Naples, Italy. ©KettiWilhelm2020

How Italians Stay Thin Eating Pizza & Pasta All the Time

More of the Latest:

  • Pasta With Broccoli: A Recipe Stolen from My Italian In-Laws
  • How Hard Is It to Go to Hawaii Right Now? (And Should You?)
  • Plastic-Free Toiletries: My Travel-Friendly, Less-Waste Routine

Follow the Facebook Page:

Support Tilted Map:

If you enjoy what I write and want to share the ❤️, you can contribute $5 here! xoxo

Search the Blog:

Booking.com Hotel Search:

This form takes you to Booking.com (with the same selection & prices) and a fraction of your hotel bill will help me run this website – at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support!

Booking.com

LastObject – Use TILTEDMAP10 for 10% off!

The words "Black Friday" crossed out, with "Green November" beneath. For each product sold in November, LastObject collects 2 lbs/ 1 kg of plastic in cooperation with Plastic Bank. (An alternative to a Black Friday campaign.)

Want to Read More? Subscribe below!

If you get my posts via social media, that's great! But those websites change their algorithms all the time, and that can leave people not seeing my posts. Signing up for emails is the surest way to see when I write something new!

Privacy Policy

(Don't worry, I never send more than one email a week. Often less.)

Van Part 7 - Flooring! Damn, it's hard to make thi Van Part 7 - Flooring! Damn, it's hard to make this sexy. 😂  As you can tell from the video, it was a pretty slow, tedious, precision type of job. (Which, frankly, my nerd heart loves. ❤)  But that doesn’t explain why I’m acting like an insane person who hasn’t slept. It’s not drugs. It was the Saturday after election day, and I was feeling all those hope-y, change-y feelings. Anyone else remember that?  I still believe in it. The best is yet to come. And someday I’ll be able to get a haircut, too. 💇 ✌
Continuing the van building distraction: Part 6, T Continuing the van building distraction: Part 6, The Wood Ceiling! 🌲  Made from leftover Blue Pine boards piled in my dad's shop, stained by yours truly, and painstakingly wedged into place on an uneven, curved ceiling.  Definitely a square peg / round hole kind of job, but it makes this old Chevy feel like a cabin in the woods! 💚
My mind has been far away from our van project lat My mind has been far away from our van project lately, so I'm a few steps behind in sharing this story. But here we go – Part 5: climbing around on top of a car like a '50s pin-up model, but with more '90s grunge vibes. 🔧 💃  🎬 Video of course by @theaviaoexperience
You may have noticed my stories got a little vulga You may have noticed my stories got a little vulgar and angry and political yesterday. Well, expressing how I feel about what happened in my country yesterday required a lot of fucks.  But first, congratulations to @raphaelwarnock and @jonossoff , who both broke barriers yesterday!  As for the rest of it, well…  This might seem like a break from my usual travel posts, but it’s not. Travel IS political, and I write about it as such. Travel writers and bloggers SHOULD ABSOLUTELY talk about what’s really happening in a place – politics and oppression included.  We’re quick to point out when other countries are unsafe to visit, but what about our own? 
Of all the wealthy democracies I’ve visited and lived in, I've never seen a place with such  terrifying hypocrisy as the United States. And I’m on the easy side of it – I’m white!!  My favorite political science professor in college said, “The only defining marker of a stable democracy is the peaceful transition of power.”  Yesterday, the only “stable” thing I saw was the predictable impunity for white thugs and domestic terrorists who stormed Congress like out-of-control children – because they lost an election. And because they knew they could get away with it. No person of color would ever imagine they could do that in this country.  That is the REALITY OF AMERICA TODAY. And the world is watching.  How could ANYONE abroad see a country where anyone can have a gun, and any hostile, armed (white) person with a grudge can walk into the highest offices of government without being stopped, and think: “That sounds like a nice place for a vacation”?  This is the kind of impunity and lawlessness that makes the US State Department warn us not to visit other countries.  So tell me, if you’re thinking of visiting the USA as a traveler, how safe does it seem right now???  📸 : Photo is from a Trump protest in Chicago back in 2019. The sentiment is what we still have to live up to.
.
.
#thisisamerica #travelusa #travelbloggersofig
#travelblogging
My mantra for the new year. ☝️ I’m looking f My mantra for the new year. ☝️ I’m looking forward to lots more change, new gigs, moving, exploring, learning and, just like last year, adapting to and learning to do things I never thought I could. (Just hopefully more fun things. 🏄‍♀️ 🧳)  Whatever you’ve got in mind, here's to 2021!
.
.
#findyouradventure #newyear2021 #newyearnewgoals #itravelbecause
Follow on Instagram

Footer

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter

Subscribe to Posts via Email

(Emails once a week or less.)

How to Support This Blog ❤️

If you enjoy what I write, you can contribute a few "thank you" dollars here!

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
Ethical Influencers member logo.

Blog
About
Contact
Work With Me
Privacy Policy
Resources

Searching for Something?

Get easy updates on Facebook:

Tilted Map

Copyright © 2021 · Ketti Wilhelm & Ketti Wilhelm Communications LLC | All Rights Reserved